by Emily Ross
Hello, fellow history enthusiasts!
Today, we’ll be dissecting the early years of the Jamestown colony, which laid the groundwork for the American Revolution. Get comfy, because this tale is one wild ride!
Ok. Now the goods.
Grab a beer and let's get into how the new Jamestown colony descended into Lord of the Flies.
Contents
Setting the Scene
Let’s rewind a bit. Up until now, colonists had set off for Virginia on three ships, thanks to the bankroll of the Virginia Company. This company played it safe by sealing the names of those who'd govern the new colony in a secret box, only to be opened on arrival. Smart idea, right? Keep everyone calm and cooperative on the journey over. Well, sort of.
John Smith: Hero or Villain?
Enter John Smith, a daring adventurer with a controversial reputation. Just getting there was problematic. Rumors ran rampant; some folks were scared stiff that Smith planned a hostile takeover. These whispers whipped up enough paranoia to get Smith jailed before even setting foot in Virginia!
Surprise, surprise—his name was indeed in that secret box as a council member. Talk about an awkward unboxing! They soon realized the accusations were bogus. But the damage was done, and mistrust was brewing.
Chaos and Council Drama
The council's first order of business? Everything. Who cuts the wood? Who cooks? The basics of survival. But instead of adulting, the council members acted more like bickering teens. The seven-man council quickly became a battlefield of insults and power struggles.
A Game of Thrones: Jamestown Edition
The tension escalated with the case of Captain Kendall, labeled the troublemaker and swiftly voted off the council. More drama ensued as surviving council members started kicking each other out or dying of diseases like scurvy. The council rapidly dwindled to just four, including the president, who was as ineffective as a gavel in a shouting match.
John Smith Takes Charge
Smith took over as president, mostly by default. And spoiler alert—he wasn’t much better. Council members kept fighting, and governing fell apart. But then, Captain Newport arrived with supplies and more colonists. This guy was practically a superhero, swooping in just in time to prevent Smith’s execution and restore some semblance of order.
Revolution Seeds: Early Governance Lessons
Despite Newport’s interventions, the council’s dysfunction was a preview of things to come. Their inability to govern sparked ideas that would fuel revolutionary thoughts: the need for elected local representatives and established rights of Englishmen even in the colonies.
The Downward Spiral
Fast forward to 1608. The colonists were starving, leadership was a mess, and Smith was back in jail, accused of mutiny. The arrival of more supplies and new council members like Richard Waldo and Peter Wynn briefly stabilized things. But this was short-lived.
Smith’s ruling era ended with a literal bang—an explosion injured him, forcing a return to England. Newport’s shipwreck and lost official documents meant temporary chaos—until surviving papers finally ended the council’s reign, setting up a governor-led system.
What a tale, right? This story is a perfect example of how fragile early colonial governance was and how these early conflicts planted the seeds for future rebellion. Thanks for reading!
Stay tuned for next week’s episode, where we'll dig into the sickness and starvation that nearly obliterated Jamestown, and how a certain marriage brought a flicker of hope.
Subscribe to our free history newsletter so you never miss an episode!
